Harry Potter- no question.

It's a hard call. As much as I LOVED the Twilight books, the movie was a disappointment. The Harry Potter book and movies were amazing. So I'd have to go with Harry Potter.

harry potter :)

Twilight all the way .

TWILIGHT, DUH! haha.
Harry Potter waited much too long and it all just kind of died out for me really.. I do hope New Moon will be better though, it already looks better then Twilight thats for sure!

TWILIGHT I loved the books, I think robert pattinson plays edward perfectly, and taylor lautner is so cute :D

TWILIGHT,

THE BOOKS WERE AMAZING...COULDN'T PUT THEM DOWN! THE MOVIE WAS GOOD, COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER, HOPEFULLY THE BUDGET ALLOWS FOR A BETTER SEQUAL, NEW MOON LOOKS GREAT!

TWILIGHT!!

Harry Potter by a million country miles.

Harry Potter, no doubt!

who are we trying to kid? TWILIGHT clearly leave sHarry Potter in the dust!!

Harry Potter all the way!!

twilight!! who would be crazy enough NOT to pick it!! I luv u Robert pattinson!!!

Harry Potter, no question

I thought Twilight was good, but sort of insulting to all the old-school vampires. If I want a vampire book, I'll stick with Anne Rice ;D. Harry Potter gets my vote.

Harry Potter. No comparison

Harry Potter all the way, though i loved twilight, Harry Potter will always be the one.
ps. happy bday jkrowling and harrypotter :D

HARRY POTTER ALL THE WAY TWILIGHT SUCKS!!!

The Harry Potter books were boring for me .. I'm sorry to those who liked the books but they just didn't do it for me, not like the twilight books did anyway. They were phenominal the Twilight books! But as someone mentioned the movie was a disappointment, the HP movies were very very good. Tough choice for me.

Definately Harry Potter...
That dude from twilight looks like he needs a shower..

HP all the way...and I am a fan of Twilight also, but Harry Potter is in totally superior.

twilight allllllll the way! :)

TWILIGHT ALL THE WAY!!!!!
I LOVE ROBERT!!!!!
<3

TWILIGHT...no questions asked :)

Harry Potter for sure..... it's a magical fantasy people of all ages can imagine and hope for.....

TWILIGHT!!!

Twilight baby! Harry Potter is wayyyy too fake for me, the characters were KIDS! My 8 year old likes Harry Potter!

harry potter for sure =]

HARRY FREAKING POTTER!!

SO much better than Twilight. GAH Harry Potter made me cry it was so good. Maybe not the movies, but the BOOKS!

twilight all the way....i friggin love it...the books are awsome van't wait to see the movie new moon

Harry Potter :)

I WOULD HAVE TO SAY ALSO THAT THE TWILIGHT MOVIE WAS A DISSAPOINTMENT SO YEAH HARRY POTTER ALL THE WAY AND HE IS BECOMMING A GOOD LOOKING MAN, I THINK, THATS JUST ME!

Twilight! no competition!

harry potter is so weak so I have to go with TWILIGHT!

Twilight! the books are amazing and I love Robert.

Twilight!!!!!

I love my husband to death.

Twilight hands down.

Twilight baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I hated harry pothead, he sucked!! way too kidish.

Twilight all the way, harry potter sucks! Robert Pattinson is freakin sexii! :)

Twilight, Twilight, Twilight!!!!! Go Team Emmett!!

i don't know because i like both twilight and harry potter. so i will have to say both

TWILIGHTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

I've never read all of the Harry Potter books, but I have read Twilight and it was absoluetly an AMAZING saga so I'll go with Twilight :D

I'm for Harry Potter all the way!!!

Twilight saga all the way :D!!!!

Nothing even compares to TWILIGHT! xo

Twilight all the way!!!!!!!!!!!

Twilight & Harry Potter were both good for me...Hard to choose. But the harry potter books were boring and the twilight books were amazing! <3 Taylor Lautner!!!

Harry Potter, hands down. Such amazing actors and let's face it, JKR is pretty much God. The Twilight books were great, plot-wise, but were horribly written. And the movie was baaaaad!
Harry Potter's got it all!

TWILIGHT TWILIGHT TWILIGHT!!! Gosh y would anyone ever wanna pick Harry Potter?! YUCK!

nvm of wat i said before i'm totally with my sexy lover harry potter!

TWILIGHT!!!!!!

Twilight is garbage. The writing style, descriptive language, plot, characters and overall tone of the books are simply awful. Harry Potter is rich in depth, deeply symbolic, fun, adventurous and overall magical. There is no competition.

Twilight is too over-rated, and not that great to be honest. I think Harry Potter wins this one, again :)

HARRY POTTER all the way!!!!!!!!!!

TWILIGHT!!! For the Vampires and love! And Harry Potter for the adventure! So Both! But I get more excited for Twilight! :)

TWILIGHT IS THE BEST!!!!

the twilight books were good, but i really didnt like the movie. the harry potter books are amazing, and so are the movies, so i guess HARRY POTTER WINS!

Harry Potter, hands down. Not only are the movies incredibly wel done, the books are well written.

HARRY POTTER

HARRY EFFIN POTTER YOWWWWWWWWW

TWILIGHT!!

that's easy it's twilight i love the movie and the books

Let's not forget who came first, there will only ever be Harry Potter for me, I've read them both and I still say HARRY FOREVER!

yeah rightt, everyone loooooves twilight!!!

The Twilight books were great, movie could have been better. I did not really like the Harry Potter books but the movies are really really good.


can't choose

I CHANGE MY MIND TWILIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NEVER MIND I SAY BOTH! READ ALL OF THE BOOKS HARRY POTTER AND TWLIGHT. IM NOT GOING TO CHOOSE

TWILIGHT LOVE TAYLOR SOOO MUCH hehehehehe Roberts awesome too but I'm all about Taylor

Twilight. It's not even a contest. Harry Potter was too fantasy-ish for my taste. Rob's...mmmm...hehe I shouldn't be saying that. Oh well, I also love taylor.

Twilight for sure !!! Aggghhh so sexy ;)

Harry Potter- no question. Twilight is more like a second not as good Harry Potter. Harry Potter also has a bettr plot to the storyy.The only thing is Taylor Lautner is SSOO HOT!!!

I took a talley and so farr Twilight winss. 35-Twilight 28-Harry Potter and 4-Can't Chose

I personallyy LOVE Harry Potter no competion. :)

twilight is the best

I love Harry Potter, but I'll have to say Twilight. The books are great. The movie's good, too.

i think, that the books for twilight and harry potter are both amazing, but i just love twilight so much, even though the movie wasnt that good, and harry potter movies are good, i love twilight so much, that it gets my vote :D

TWILIGHT!!!! All the way harry potter is ugly and the movie that just came out sucks balls

HARRRRRY POTTER ALL THE WAY NO IFS ANDS OR BUTS !!!!!!!!! SCREW TWILIGHT!

TWILIGHT BABY!!! EDWARD IS MY DREAM MAN!<3<3<3<3 TWILIGHT KICKS HARRY POTTERS A** ANYDAY!

i just finished all the harry potter books (better late than never) but they were AMAZING...twilight was decent but the movie was a big disappointment - harry potter all the way!

That can be a tricky one, Twilight has been the only thing in almost 10 years that has come anywhere near close to rivaling my Harry Potter OBSESSION. Granted If I could choose between Harry or Edward, I'd get freaky with Edward, hands down. But, that being said Matel just came out with Twilight Barbies (Bella and Edward only - so far), will I get them, no, However, if they came out with Harry Potter Barbies I would snap those up faster than you can say "Hedwig". So I would have to say Harry Potter, mostly because the lackluster movie did nothing for the book.

No matter how hard I try, I absolutely can't understand the appeal of Harry Potter...lame characters, (mostly) unattractive actors, childish plot, and no sex-appeal whatsoever. On the other hand, I tried NOT to love Twilight, simply to keep my semi-badass reP***tion in tact...and failed epically. It's hot, fun, guiltily delicious, and constantly intriguing. The series went from "wow, that was surprisingly interesting", to "HOLY GEEZ I'M SO INTO THIS!". Also, the casting director is a genius...from Edward to Alice to Bella's dad, everybody was selected with stunning accuracy!

TWILIGHT !

I can't believe a literary masterpiece such as HP is even being compared to Twilight!! Twilight is S*** - albeit good, sexy S*** that is obviously appealing to tweens to middle aged women, but HP is much more than that and doesn't depend on its sex appeal and "vampires".

Twilight! I loved the books. The movie was alright. Books are always better though.
Harry Potter was really good at first but after the 3rd book/movie it got out of hand! After reading the 4th book i got bored.
Who knows, maybe that will happen with twilight too but it`s still such a new thing.

Sorry, someone said this and I had to write... I love a lot of books, Harry Potter among them, and the last three books really were quite complex and deep... yes, they involved children but that doesn't mean they didn't have complexity...

HARRY POTTER!!

Twilight was soo boring. I literally fell asleep while reading it.

Harry potter is AMAZING!! i like it for a number of reasons.

1. Harry potter shows that the women can do watever guys can do. Hermione, Tonks, or Mrs. Weasley dont sit there and watch other ppl fight. They are strong and independant. u don't see them moping around cuz a guy.

unlike twilight, where Bella is sooo dependant on edward that it is just obsessvive. she lives cuz of edward, wat does that teach the girls of this generation.

2. J.K rowling spent over 10 years on the plot. while Meyers dreamed about it.
so, the hp plot is soo captivating.

3. Harry potter is very thought out. thats why it is soo understandable. no twilight fan has ever said anything bout the plot being good or not. just 'edward is sooo hot'

4. twilight is a bore!!! bella thinks for bout half the book (i love edward, i m sad, i m happy) and the other half is spent on describing edward. Amazing story. (note the sarcasm).

Both are good Harry Potter id very intersting because it has all this mithical stuff in it like the sorwd in the stone and King Arther both books are pretty sweet loved the Half Blood Prience movie lolz fave book was book seven lolz <3 love u Tom Felton!!!!!! :D :P

Harry Potter. No question. HARRY POTTER RULES!!

Harry Potter is better in every way shape and form. It's a shame that the Twilighters are too shallow to know what makes a good book. Of course, Meyer is the most shallow person on the planet.

JK Rowling is full of depth and cleverness. As is Harry Potter.

Harry Potter > Twilight.

GO HARRY POTTER!!

Ron and Hermione are a better couple than any Twilight pairing could EVER hope to be.

Bella and Edward aren't even in love. It's lust and obsession, caused by none of the characters actually having a life.

Ron and Hermione is real love. You could tell from the very first time they met that they would end up together. <3

Twilight fails.

Harry Potter is an epic win.

I THREW ECLIPSE OUT THE WINDOW!! IT WAS SO MUCH FUN!! TWILIGHT SUCKS!! THE BOOK SOON BROKE BEYOND REPAIR AND I LAUGHED!!

DOWN WITH TWILIGHT!!

Twilight is an embarrassment to vampires everywhere. Vampires should NOT sparkle. I'd love to see who'd win, the Cullens vs. Anne Rice vampires. Anne Rice's vampires would kick the Cullen's @$$.

Harry Potter is inspiring and creative, as well as deep. I don't know any character in any book that can compare to Snape. Genius. Pure genius.

Oh, and HARRY POTTER HAS A FRIGGEN PLOT!!

LMFAO!! READ THE COMMENTS TRYING TO SHOW HOW AMAZING TWILIGHT IS! SERIOUSLY?? HOW COULD ANYONE BE SO SHALLOW??

This is the Twitard's argument:
The Twilight characters are prettier than the Harry Potter ones.

Pathetic.

A couple of Harry Potter arguments:
-It's DEEP
-It HAS A PLOT
-Female characters aren't all pathetic and needy like Mary Sue - oops, I mean Bella.
-It's well developed
-It's creative
-It makes you THINK
-It connects much better with the reader
-It's for all ages
-It understands what school is really like (No, Stephenie Meyer, not all students are either poP***r or supernatural. Get your facts strait)
-Speaking of getting the facts strait, JK Rowling knows her history, and uses it. (Honestly? Rosalie had not been poor because her father was a bank owner? It's called RESEARCH. The Great Depression happened because the banks FAILED)
-Harry Potter doesn't contradict itself
-Harry Potter is more than whining about how suckish life is and how beautiful an abusive vampire is
-Harry Potter has good morals

AND MORE!! Those are just a very small fraction of reasons why the Harry Potter books are better. Don't even get me started on the movies.

This is Twilight:
Bella: I hate my life!
1 paragraph later
Bella: EDWARD IS SO PRETTY. I LOVE HIM
Edward: You're hot, Bella
Bella: I WANNA LIVE FOREVER AND BE PRETTY!! WAHHH!!
Edward: Yeah, living forever is the best thing in the universe.
A few pages later...
Edward: This is who you can be friends with. This is who you can't be friends with.
Bella: BUT I WANNA BE FRIENDS WITH THAT PERSON!!
Edward: TOO BAD!! I'M THE GUY, I GET TO SAY WHAT GOES!! HAHAHA!!
Bella: Oh, he's just being caring. That's not abuse! Not at all!

Epic fail.

Harry Potter wins.

Twilight is just a fad. Everyone loves it now, but it will soon be forgotten. Dead.

Harry Potter will live on forever. It is a classic. It will be remembered as long as literature is around, which will hopefully be as long as the Earth is around.

The only smart thing about Twilight is the author who is sitting back and collecting millions for writing a bad novel for tweens. How can you even compare this contrived piece of crap to Harry Potter?

The movies are worlds apart, as well.

twilight in books and potter in...... nothing!
i read 1 paragraph in potter and fell asleep! movie had no desire but my cousin dragged me into it. fell asleep again! twilight is a great book but the movie five minutes in i fell asleep! (what is it with me and sleeping!)

HARRY POTTER. definitely.
i was half way through the twilight & i had to keep checking the back to see if i was reading the right book because i swear i read that there would be a vampire in it but it took forever for it to finally get out. there are so many plot holes, the characters are too perfect, & it's all black & white with almost no grays (dumbledore: good, but not completely; he fights for the light side, but he's also maniP***tive.); smeyer needs an editor, she goes against the rules of her world just to give edward a baby & a happy ending. & there's the big thing. HAPPY ENDINGS; they're just not realistic. in real life, while it won't always suck, you don't get everything thing you want, but in the end, despite the losses, you're at least satisfied.

Harry Potter all the way!!! So sad the books have reached their end :(

Harry Potter!!!!!!

MOST DEFINETLY HARRY POTTER!!! OMG I JUST HOPE THERES LIKE ANOTHER SERIES BY JKR ABOU HARRYS LIFE NOW THAT HE IS OLDER (RANDOM WISH)
BUT SERIOUSLY HARRY POTTER ROCKEED!!! AND CANNOT BE COMPARED TO TWILIGHT!
HP GETS MY VOTE TIMES A THOUSAND!
:)

Even though I am a fan of Twilight I am still going with Harry Potter cause itwas written way better than Twilight was. It had so much to it and so many characters and was written by a talented author while Twilight was just a simple creation written by an amateur. The Harry Potter movie has no romance in it but it still was better. GO HARRY POTTER!!!

Oh Harry Potter for sure! Written so much better than those 'vampire' books...

First of all, I wish Stephenie Meyer used a thesaurus when she was writing the Twilight series. There is an enormous lack of character building, style, and unpredictability. Twilight does not even come close to the professional and talented writing of J.k Rowling's series Harry Potter.

I like both Harry Potter & Twilight

to those who say S. Meyer goes against the rules... whose rules? Who said vamps are supposed to have pointy teeth, turn to dust with the sun? Some one out there made up that version of a vamp didn't they! As I once saw... S. Meyer stated in an interview that she wanted to go against the norm for her book... GOOD FOR HER I say.

I loved both series of books. The Twilight movie I was disappointed with sure... but I was equally disappointed with some of the H.P movies. We unfortunately can't have everything now can we... besides where would we put it all.

harry potter definitely.

Twilight is the best!

Hands Down Harry Potter!
The Twilight series was OK, but disappointing! You read through all the books expecting something big to happen in the end and....nothing! Snore! Harry Potter definitely has the stronger story line.
Oh and girls, if your going by "hots" - guess what!? Robert Pattinson was in Harry Potter too!

Harry Potter.

it looks like Harry Potter wins...

Neither.... not a huge fan of something just because it's a hit to the rest of the world. I read the whole Twilight series so it's not like I'm judging as someone who hasn't even read or seen the Harry Potter series. I like the story of twilight, do NOT like the method and style of writing, dislike the movie and the lack of a soundtrack even more. Harry Potter I can't say anything against per se except I don't follow the story line so I'm not a big fan of things that confuse me..

Twilight))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
))))

Harry Potter all the way. k well i really love the twilght movies but i am like in love with the movies an books of harry potter

Twilight is the most boring, stupidest vampire story ever. I would never want my daughter to emulate a airhead like Bella!